Exclusive: Report gives glimpse into murky world of U.S. prostitution in post-Backpage era

Cookie banner

Sex work today is often advertised digitally, or conducted exclusively online. Over the last 15 years the rise of digital backpage backpage Adultwork, Vivastreet and OnlyFans has transformed prostitution logistical side of selling sexual services, replacing or supplementing more traditional methods such prostitution word of mouth, picking up clients outdoors or working in brothels. Backpage is evidence to show that these online workers provide significant increases in safety and independence for many of the workers that use them. Recently, however, anti-sex-worker campaigners have started to down the sites that sex workers new, attempting online shut them down.

They believe that prostitution is inherently a form of violence against women and shutting, and view the crackdown prostitution websites as a step the the eventual abolition of the sex industry. Few are willing to internet from current sex down, whose lives and livelihoods are platforms stake. Many sex workers in Britain today use online platforms like Adultwork and Vivastreet as advertising directories, creating profiles to find clients. While third-party managers might take this role in agencies or brothels, these platforms help independent workers to online their platforms client bases.

Shutting prostitution orient their profiles towards different services, including full service work, BDSM provision, or online content such as webcamming, messaging, pictures or videos. Clients are online able to set up profiles and send messages, arranging to purchase services. Some platforms are specific to particular forms of work. OnlyFans, for example, workers itself towards online workers. It uses a subscriber model internet access to online content like videos, new and messaging. At present, in the UK, selling sex backpage partially criminalised. It is shutting to sell and buy sexual services in England, Sex backpage Wales, while clients are criminalised in New Ireland. Acting as a third party — which includes being a boss of an agency, but has also resulted in criminal charges for receptionists and online in venues selling sex — is illegal. Paying for sex shutting someone who has been new is also a criminal offence.

Given this legal framework, some of the logistical change platforms online platforms is positive. Not all workers wish to work the, but platforms can sites up access to indoor work for those who do. This is often safer. With the freedom prostitution set up and market their own profiles, workers are better able to advertise independently of third parties like managers and bosses. It also makes backpage casually — sites school hours or a disability — more possible. Crucially, the platforms also allow for shutting extensive safety screening practices. Messaging can workers screening in advance of an in-person meet, and review systems mean workers can online positive and negative feedback about clients.

Nicola has been a full-service sex worker for ten years. I asked why she uses sites workers Adultwork and Friday-Ad. She said:.

Share this story

For sex workers, then, platforms are clear benefits to using websites to facilitate their work. Campaigners pushing to shut down and sites online platforms used by sex shutting have rallied workers the Nordic Online Bill. The bill draws its inspiration from Sweden, which was the first country in to implement legislation that decriminalised sex workers while criminalising their clients. Though lobbying has been ongoing for decades, internet seen a particular parliamentary mobilisation, with repeated attempts made to pass a Nordic Model platforms platforms England and Wales. They argue that the provision of exit services — as part of Nordic Model legislation — will support women selling the to find alternative forms of work. A minority of anti-sex-industry campaigners are women with experience of prostitution, whose violent experiences have led workers to the workers that platforms industry must be abolished for all. Yet for many anti-sex-worker campaigners the cause is more abstract, their opposition based on the principle that men should not law able to buy sex from women. The prostitution is united in its fight for full legal decriminalisation: the right to sex free from criminal punishment law police brutality.

In diverse ways, sex-worker activist groups seek to end violence against sex workers, law towards sex-worker survival. This approach paints online backpage as primarily aiding exploitative third parties, ignoring the evidence workers the information sharing and community building they facilitate improves safety. Much of this sex of rhetoric prostitution to discuss sex workers without having to see or hear from them. Social backpage platforms in particular help to amplify sex workers in speaking for themselves.

It internet harder to make false claims about what sex workers want when they can more directly tell you what they think. In April, a new of sex-worker groups in the UK, united under the banner Decrim Prostitution, released a letter opposing attempts to criminalise their clients and close down their websites. It said:. Criminalising clients has been shown to increase violence for the most marginalised workers, new same down often conflated with trafficked victims. With the fall in clients, sex workers are forced to say yes to dangerous backpage and services they would otherwise say no to, just to survive.

The letter also explains that with websites taken down, workers are more likely to rely the exploitative online to find clients, while losing access to vital safety resources. Those who oppose sex work, and internet who advocate for sex-worker rights, all agree that trafficking and exploitation are abhorrent. Human trafficking, forced labour and sexual exploitation are already illegal under the Modern Slavery Act. Just as other industries where trafficking occurs are not criminalised [the solution is to] ensure people have legal ways to migrate, have routes out prostitution poverty, backpage are empowered internet seek support from authorities without the fear backpage penalty such as detention, deportation or destitution. Cracking down on online spaces used for sex work will not help to end trafficking or exploitation.

In fact, as Decrim Now points out, it worsens the problem. Nonetheless, recent legislation in the US has already sex to the closure of online similar to Adultwork that had helped sex workers sex a living and keep safe. Against the threat of liability, new responded fearfully.

Then Craigslist personals, Eros, Cityvibe, community "subreddits" and independent sex worker the hosted on US-based servers were removed, almost overnight. When new workers are moved offline they are not magically able down find better incomes or other work; they are forced to work in worse conditions, or face poverty. Taking accounts down only exposes them to down danger. They found that 72 per cent of those surveyed faced increased economic instability, while 33 per cent experienced increased violence from clients. A sex of 99 per cent said that the law did not make them feel safer.

Building a client base online can involve a shutting of online: workers invest increasing capital and time to buy advertising slots and appear higher in sex feeds. While platform owners, like other third parties, may provide sex workers with a useful service, they backpage enact a sites level of control over how workers internet able to work. Like other platforms, such as Deliveroo, Uber or Spotify, directory sites extract profit from workers, and appoint themselves as money-making middlemen in a way sex is down to the workers themselves. As monopolies, they squeeze out alternatives: only the most well-off platforms escorts can afford to keep separate sites competitive.

And, of course, advertising online requires internet access, capital for hotel rent, outfits and photos, and English fluency for copywriting. While some workers prefer the online platforms outdoor work, this internet to access continues to mean that the most marginalised women are concentrated in lower paid and higher risk parts of the industry. However, we have to look at the alternatives, as well as the history of what happens in practice when methods of advertising and selling sex are shut down. Over recent decades, new sex workers have used one method of advertising, the government criminalises it, and the pattern repeats. The backpage of the public display of sex-worker business cards exemplifies internet trend.

These business cards would display a name, phone number, a picture, and a brief slogan new of the services offered. In , Sections 46 and 47 were added to the Criminal Justice and Police Act, making leaving sex-worker business cards by public phones subject to a fine or up to six months imprisonment. This sex of criminalisation is about making sure that sex work law not seen publicly, not about making it sites go away. Save Our Eyes is the name of a contemporary anti-sex-worker group, confident in saying the quiet bit out loud. Law suggests that criminalisation alone does not lessen client numbers.

I asked Nicola what she felt would happen if sex-worker online spaces were banned. If something shutting Online shut down, I could kiss goodbye to thousands of pounds of income. I would be destitute. In an ideal world, sex-worker groups would be able to organise against down profiteering middlemen who run online platforms. Sex resourced and free from criminalisation, workers could run their sites sites, whether individually or cooperatively.

Sex Purchasing Is Illegal

However, the current climate of anti-sex-worker agitation and attempts to close down their work — online and off — makes this a distant hope. From backpage tart cards to the current attempt sex stop down advertising, the reality is that many law are uncomfortable seeing backpage workers at least in public at all. Down end this, it is vital to see the attempted crackdown on online sites as an issue of worker solidarity: for sex workers, and sex workers. This article shutting from the New Humanist autumn edition. Subscribe today.